One more junior's voice

So many people have taken to the internet to express a lot of what I am about to reiterate too. Much of it is written with greater thought, clarity and passion than I can hope to here. But there is no defense in omitting such an important topic from my so-called blog. A few plagiarised images will have to suffice in trying to express these concerns.

I really have no idea what the general public know or think about what is happening to the NHS as I type this. All of my professional contacts and a large proportion of my personal ones work for the NHS in one way or another, and each of them feel similarly numb and impotent and downhearted by the situation we find ourselves in. The current handling of the NHS via its funding, organisation and staffing very directly affects me and the people I know. But it also directly affects every single NHS user as chronic underfunding of services and maltreatment staff will inevitably lead to cracks that will continue to erode the service and endanger patients.

I spent 4 years at medical school, and 7 years at university in total. Clearly it wasn’t a particularly efficient way of gaining employability, but even the most decisive school leaver must spend a minimum of 5 years as a student before they qualify as a doctor – and current students now pay £9,000 per year for the tuition fees alone. As a recent graduate I might spend ten or more years as a junior doctor, but even if I were to choose the fastest possible path, and succeed at every hurdle along the way, they would need to spend at least five years before becoming a GP or consultant.

Not even two months into this journey the government brutalise the system by pushing through a contract universally opposed, representing a long list of kicks not least of which is an expected 10-40% pay cut for trainee doctors. This takes junior doctor pay to pre-2000 levels and is a near-fatal blow to the morales of staff throughout the country. Furthermore the contract redefines "social working hours" to include 7am-10pm, 6 days a week. The BMA, with backing from doctors, made it clear that this was unacceptable and were unable to negotiate from here but the contract will be rolled out from Aug 2016 regardless.

 This is not the way I expected to start the career I had waited so long to begin; feeling betrayed, undervalued and impotent. We feel we deserve to be treated better, and it is this that is ominous for the future of the NHS. Even before this recent revelation I was well aware that there are far far more attractive employment opportunities for doctors outside of the UK, most foundation doctors I’ve spoken to had entertained the idea of leaving the NHS, either for a few years or permanently .There is a current retention crisis; doctors are choosing to retire earlier or change careers, and there are unfilled training posts in several key specialties including GP and A+E. As things stand these problems can only be significantly worsened in years to come. Understaffing is already a huge problem, with gaps only superficially filled with expensive locum and agency staff. The cycle is bleak:  inadequate staffing causes increased stress and mistakes, the service is less satisfying for staff and patients and so more doctors drop out of the game.

I do a small amount of e-mentoring for prospective medicine applicants, and I am quite often a source of information and advice for applying friends and family or work experience students at hospital. I now feel that it would be dishonest to recommend this path for the nations bright, optimistic and dedicated students. There are certainly other careers that pay far better, careers where you might feel respected or valued, and possibly even where you might have a better chance at a work-life balance.

This is a very good account about the situation, from the point of view of an ITU trainee doctor, and another excellent one here from an A+E trainee.

According to the BMA it costs about £260,000 to train an FY1 doctor, and a further £300,000 to train them to consultant level. New doctors will now find it difficult to even pay off their loans. It simply does not make sense in my head to invest so deeply in training medical staff only to be apparently unconcerned when many of them feel they have no option but leave the NHS. To me it sends a message that there is no concern for the future of the NHS, it seems that consciously or not the NHS is being set up to fail so that in the not-too distant future we are led to believe that the NHS is an unworkable idea  and privatisation is the only solution.

The level of outrage amongst staff, both junior and senior, medical and non, has been visceral and overwhelming. We share a keen sense of injustice but are struggling to find a constructive voice. Today my facebook wall is alive with righteous anger, though the audience reached may often be mostly other junior doctors. We cannot sleepwalk towards deeply unfair, short sighted and dangerous reforms and I will begin by joining many others in writing to my MP. It seems clear to me that a well funded and well functioning health service (available to all) is of vital importance to a nation, and a workforce that is present without resentment is essential for this. It is a message that I have no confidence that Jeremy Hunt has heard, and we are becoming exasperated at his continued inability to understand the issues surrounding healthcare delivery, and his continued refusal to hear the concerns of the public or the professions.  Clearly the recent petition re a vote of no confidence achieved very little despite overwhelming support (220,000 signatures and Mr Hunt did not attend the debate). I am concerned that the collective voice of doctors in the UK will continue to be ignored and some sort of strike action becomes unavoidable. I doubt this can be achieved without alienating the public or putting patients in harm’s way but there is far too much at stake to do nothing.

Some background and media coverage
http://www.bma.org.uk/working-for-change/in-depth-junior-and-consultant-contract/junior-doctor-contract-negotiations-home

http://www.independent.co.uk/voices/comment/i-dont-blame-doctors-for-walking-out-of-pay-negotiations-with-the-government-10506483.html

http://www.theguardian.com/society/2015/sep/18/junior-doctors-new-contract-cut-pay-40-per-cent

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/health/news/11875628/Junior-doctors-threaten-strike-over-new-contracts.html

http://metro.co.uk/2015/09/20/doctors-are-being-pushed-to-strike-over-new-contracts-which-will-risk-patients-lives-5399640/

From the Facebook page of Dr Philip Lee MBBS MRCP(UK)(Geriatric Medicine)
Consultant Physician in Acute Medicine and Care of the Elderly